REI Lense

REI Lense

Lancaster, NY Mid-Term Rental Analysis

Analyze rental property cap rates, cash-on-cash returns, and cashflow for mid-term rental investments in Lancaster, NY. Based on 20+ datapoints.

Lancaster, NY Mid-Term Rental Investment Snapshot

Based on 20+ mid-term rental datapoints

Median Cap Rate

6.1%

Avg Cash on Cash

-0.2%

Median Cashflow

-$208/mo

Avg Rent Estimate

$3,537/mo

Avg Price

$360,752

Price Range

$199,000 - $689,500

Rent to Price

0.98%

okay ratio

Positive Cashflow

33%

of analyzed properties

Recent real estate investor listings analysed as mid-term rental deals in Lancaster, NY

Lancaster, NY is an emerging mid-term rental market gaining attention from investors who want LTR-style stability with stronger furnished-rent premiums. With 20+ analyzed datapoints, early metrics suggest opportunity to enter before MTR inventory matures. Current average cash-on-cash returns sit at -0.2%.

Across 20+ analyzed properties, Lancaster, NY mid-term rental investments show a median monthly cashflow of -$208 with average furnished rent estimates of $3,537/month. These figures reflect real property data, not projections.

145 Nichter Rd, Lancaster, NY 14086

Price

$689,500

Rent

$6,278

CachFlow

-$708

CoC

-5.22

Full Analysis

9 Newell Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

Price

$248,900

Rent

$2,402

CachFlow

-$223

CoC

-3.81

Full Analysis

44 Stephens Ct, Lancaster, NY 14086

Price

$399,000

Rent

$3,968

CachFlow

-$245

CoC

-2.89

Full Analysis

116 Michaels Walk, Lancaster, NY 14086

Price

$431,600

Rent

$4,335

CachFlow

-$234

CoC

-2.58

Full Analysis

25 Cayuga Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086

Price

$199,000

Rent

$3,270

CachFlow

$594

CoC

11.92

Full Analysis
1–5 of 27
1 / 6

Lancaster, NY Mid-Term Rental Market Insights

  • •Median cashflow is -$208/month — careful deal selection is essential here
  • •6.1% median cap rate reflects a balanced risk-return profile
  • •At 33% positive cashflow rate, Lancaster, NY requires selective property picks
  • •Mid-to-upper tier market with properties from $199,000 to $689,500
  • •Early-stage market data — revisit as more properties are analyzed for stronger signals

Enter a Property Address for Instant Investment Analysis

Fast and accurate real estate investment analysis