Staten Island, NY Mid-Term Rental Analysis
Analyze rental property cap rates, cash-on-cash returns, and cashflow for mid-term rental investments in Staten Island, NY. Based on 100+ datapoints.
Staten Island, NY Mid-Term Rental Investment Snapshot
Based on 100+ mid-term rental datapoints
Median Cap Rate
4.1%
Avg Cash on Cash
-8.7%
Median Cashflow
-$1,366/mo
Avg Rent Estimate
$5,199/mo
Avg Price
$803,732
Price Range
$522,900 - $1,128,800
Rent to Price
0.65%
low ratio
Positive Cashflow
3%
of analyzed properties
Recent real estate investor listings analysed as mid-term rental deals in Staten Island, NY
Staten Island, NY is a premium mid-term rental market where property values complement furnished rental income. Cap rates average 4.1%, typical of premium markets where MTR investors capture both appreciation and the rent premium furnished 30–180 day stays command over standard leases.
Across 100+ analyzed properties, Staten Island, NY mid-term rental investments show a median monthly cashflow of -$1,366 with average furnished rent estimates of $5,199/month. These figures reflect real property data, not projections.
381 Willowbrook Rd, Staten Island, NY 10314
Price
$825,000
Rent
$5,079
CachFlow
-$1,613
CoC
-10.12
422 Isabella Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306
Price
$774,999
Rent
$3,210
CachFlow
-$2,381
CoC
-15.81
35 Livingston Ct, Staten Island, NY 10310
Price
$800,000
Rent
$5,739
CachFlow
-$1,061
CoC
-6.85
172 Cortelyou Ave, Staten Island, NY 10312
Price
$950,000
Rent
$5,307
CachFlow
-$1,855
CoC
-10.23
Staten Island, NY Mid-Term Rental Market Insights
- •Median cashflow is -$1,366/month — careful deal selection is essential here
- •4.1% median cap rate is typical of appreciation-focused markets
- •At 3% positive cashflow rate, Staten Island, NY requires selective property picks
- •Premium market with properties from $522,900 to $1,128,800
- •Consider this market if your strategy favors equity growth with rental income covering holding costs