REI Lense

REI Lense

New Carlisle, OH Long-Term Rental Analysis

Analyze rental property cap rates, cash-on-cash returns, and cashflow for long-term rental investments in New Carlisle, OH. Based on 20+ datapoints.

New Carlisle, OH Long-Term Rental Investment Snapshot

Based on 20+ long-term rental datapoints

Median Cap Rate

4%

Avg Cash on Cash

-12.9%

Median Cashflow

-$692/mo

Avg Rent Estimate

$1,759/mo

Avg Price

$314,590

Price Range

$200K – $500K

approximate

Rent to Price

0.56%

low ratio

Positive Cashflow

0%

of analyzed properties

Recent real estate investor listings analysed as long-term rental deals in New Carlisle, OH

New Carlisle, OH is an emerging long-term rental market gaining investor attention. With 20+ properties analyzed, early data shows the market is developing. The median cap rate of 4% suggests room for early-mover advantage as more rental inventory becomes available.

Based on 20+ analyzed properties, the median monthly cashflow in New Carlisle, OH is -$692 with average rents of $1,759/month. Properties are priced about $200,000 to $500,000, offering entry points across multiple investment budgets.

518 Hamilton Ave, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Price

$226,000

Rent

$1,564

CachFlow

-$387

CoC

-9.79

Full Analysis

314 S Adams St, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Price

$237,300

Rent

$1,972

CachFlow

-$147

CoC

-3.54

Full Analysis

302 Bischoff Rd, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Price

$495,000

Rent

$2,057

CachFlow

-$1,719

CoC

-19.84

Full Analysis

1105 Langdale Ave, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Price

$201,700

Rent

$1,447

CachFlow

-$336

CoC

-9.52

Full Analysis

9054 Bellefontaine Rd, New Carlisle, OH 45344

Price

$290,000

Rent

$1,413

CachFlow

-$647

CoC

-12.75

Full Analysis
1–5 of 20+
Page 1

New Carlisle, OH Rental Market Insights

  • Median cashflow is -$692/month — careful deal selection is essential here
  • 4% median cap rate is typical of appreciation-focused markets
  • At 0% positive cashflow rate, New Carlisle, OH requires selective property picks
  • Mid-to-upper tier market with properties priced about $200,000 to $500,000
  • Early-stage market data — revisit as more properties are analyzed for stronger signals

Enter a Property Address for Instant Investment Analysis

Fast and accurate real estate investment analysis