REI Lense

REI Lense

Payson, AZ Long-Term Rental Analysis

Analyze rental property cap rates, cash-on-cash returns, and cashflow for long-term rental investments in Payson, AZ. Based on 20+ datapoints.

Payson, AZ Long-Term Rental Investment Snapshot

Based on 20+ long-term rental datapoints

Median Cap Rate

2.8%

Avg Cash on Cash

-15.5%

Median Cashflow

-$1,478/mo

Avg Rent Estimate

$2,686/mo

Avg Price

$656,418

Price Range

$388,900 - $1,250,000

Rent to Price

0.41%

low ratio

Positive Cashflow

0%

of analyzed properties

Recent real estate investor listings analysed as long-term rental deals in Payson, AZ

Payson, AZ is primarily an appreciation-driven market for long-term rental investors. Cap rates average 2.8%, typical of premium markets where property value growth complements rental income. Investors here build equity through appreciation while rental income covers holding costs.

Based on 20+ analyzed properties, the median monthly cashflow in Payson, AZ is -$1,478 with average rents of $2,686/month. Properties range from $388,900 to $1,250,000, offering entry points across multiple investment budgets.

1131 S Sycamore Cir, Payson, AZ 85541

Price

$679,700

Rent

$3,493

CachFlow

-$1,550

CoC

-13.03

Full Analysis

1807 E Underwood Ln, Payson, AZ 85541

Price

$1,031,800

Rent

$3,378

CachFlow

-$4,173

CoC

-23.11

Full Analysis

513 W Sherwood Dr, Payson, AZ 85541

Price

$675,000

Rent

$2,345

CachFlow

-$2,101

CoC

-17.79

Full Analysis

206 S Thunder Mountain, Payson, AZ 85541

Price

$469,900

Rent

$2,680

CachFlow

-$706

CoC

-8.59

Full Analysis

1705 E Cliff Rose Dr, Payson, AZ 85541

Price

$1,235,500

Rent

$2,614

CachFlow

-$5,723

CoC

-26.47

Full Analysis
15 of 23
1 / 5

Payson, AZ Rental Market Insights

  • Median cashflow is -$1,478/month — careful deal selection is essential here
  • 2.8% median cap rate is typical of appreciation-focused markets
  • At 0% positive cashflow rate, Payson, AZ requires selective property picks
  • Premium market with properties from $388,900 to $1,250,000
  • Consider this market if your strategy favors equity growth with rental income covering holding costs

Enter a Property Address for Instant Investment Analysis

Fast and accurate real estate investment analysis